> ## Documentation Index
> Fetch the complete documentation index at: https://docs.tilt.now/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover all available pages before exploring further.

# Approve and send trades from Trading

> Work through the proposals on the Trading page: read each account's Status and Notes, approve the accounts you want to trade, and follow each send.

**Trading** collects the proposals from your firm's latest daily check in one list. Each row's **Status** says where the account's proposal stands, and its **Notes** say why. Read the two together to decide what to do with the row.

To study one proposal's trades, taxes, and flags, see [Review a rebalance](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/review-rebalance.md). If your firm's custodian is connected through Schwab files, approved trades go into a file that you submit yourself: see [Trade at Schwab with a trade file](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-by-file-at-schwab.md).

## Who can do what

| Action | Who can do it |
| - | - |
| Read the lists and open proposals | Firm owners, editors, and viewers |
| Approve, send, and re-run the optimization | Firm owners and editors |

Your firm's [trade release rules](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-release-rules.md) can narrow who may send a particular proposal. Viewers see **Read-only. You can inspect proposals and refresh their status.**

## 1. Open the list

Open **Trading** and select **To review** if it isn't already open.

![Trading page with six numbered callouts. 1 marks the To review and Sent switch. 2 marks the line Book run completed 11/19/2026, 2:04:16 PM, 20 accounts skipped, Show. 3 marks a menu that reads Needs review (6). 4 marks the Status and Notes column headers. Seven rows follow: six accounts, each with the status Needs review and notes such as Total drift 41.9% vs 6% limit, Model allocation drift, and Cash above target, and one grouping row for a client's 3 accounts. Three accounts are ticked. 5 marks an Approve 3 accounts button beside the line 3 accounts, 12 orders selected. 6 marks Re-run optimization at the top of the page.](https://mintcdn.com/tilt/YZs0AAK5ogteslHt/images/advisor/trading-to-review.jpg?fit=max\&auto=format\&n=YZs0AAK5ogteslHt\&q=85\&s=008a7e7fdecd4228b52c1fd3454f3115)

To review on a made-up firm, with three accounts selected.

1. **To review** holds the proposals from the latest finished check. **Sent**, beside it, is a second list of every send and trade file your firm has made. A send is one approval's trades on their way to the custodian.
2. The line that begins **Book run completed** says when that check finished. **Show** lists the accounts it skipped. If a newer check is still running or failed, a notice names the check the proposals come from.
3. The menu filters the rows. It opens on **Needs review** when any account needs review. Choose **All** to find any account the check listed, then read its **Status** and **Notes** to see what happened to it.
4. **Status** and **Notes** are the columns to read first. The row also shows the **Account** with its model, and the proposal's **Value**, **Drift**, **Trades**, **Est. tax**, and **Est. cost**. In a narrow window, scroll the table sideways for the last columns.
5. The approve button acts on the rows you select.
6. **Re-run optimization** makes new proposals.

The account name opens the proposal. Accounts of one household, or of one client, sit together under a grouping row. Rows that need attention come first.

## 2. Read Status and Notes, then act

### Decide: Needs review

**Needs review** means the proposal is finished, has trades, and nobody has approved it. **Notes** say why the check listed the account, for example **Total drift 41.9% vs 6% limit** or **Cash above target**. Open the proposal, then [approve it](#3-approve-the-accounts).

Two kinds of note call for a closer look first:

* A note that begins **At current prices** or **This account has** warns that the account's cash may not cover its buys.
* A note that begins **Release rule matched:** names a [release rule](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-release-rules.md) that flagged the proposal.

If you can't select the row, **Notes** say why. **You do not have release authority for this proposal.** means a release rule or your role keeps you from sending it, so ask a member who can. **No current member can satisfy every applicable rule. An owner must repair the policy.** means an owner has to change the release rules.

### Fix: Needs attention and Skipped

**Needs attention** means something stopped the account, and **Notes** give the reason.

| Notes say | What to do |
| - | - |
| The optimization failed, or the check made no proposal | [Re-run the optimization](#re-run-the-optimization). |
| A reason that begins **Inputs changed after optimization** | The account's holdings or settings changed after the proposal was made. Re-run the optimization. |
| **A newer optimization exists for this account. Review that proposal.** | Open the account and review its newer proposal. |
| A send stopped, for example because the market was closed or an order was rejected | Select **Send again** in that send's notice above the list, when the notice offers it. If the send stopped before any order was placed, you can also re-run the optimization for a new proposal. |
| The trades couldn't go into a trade file | See [If trades stay out of the file](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-by-file-at-schwab.md#if-trades-stay-out-of-the-file). |

Other reasons name what to repair, such as the account's link to its custodian account.

**Skipped** means the check couldn't evaluate or optimize the account, so it has no proposal. **Notes** give the reason. Fix it when it's yours to fix: for **It has no model the optimizer can run.**, [assign a model](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/build-model-portfolio.md#5-assign-the-model-to-accounts). The account is evaluated again at the next check.

### Finish a trade file: Account paused

**Account paused** means a trade file that holds the account's trades isn't resolved yet. Tilt makes no new proposal for the account and takes no new approval until the file is. Select **View trade file** and [finish the file's steps](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-by-file-at-schwab.md). Other accounts keep trading, except accounts optimized together with a paused one.

### After a trade file: Exported

**Exported** means the account's trades went into a trade file, and that file no longer pauses the account. **Notes** say where the file stands for this account, and **View trade file** under the note opens it.

| Notes say | What it means | What to do |
| - | - | - |
| **Execution accounted for** | Tilt accounted for each trade you submitted for the account from the custodian's daily activity. When a trade didn't execute in full, counts after it say how each one ended, such as **2 full, 1 partial**. | Nothing. Tilt never resends an unexecuted quantity. If you still want it traded, approve it in a new proposal. |
| **Trade file cancelled** | Someone at your firm cancelled the file in Tilt. That doesn't cancel orders at Schwab, so trades from a file that was already imported there can still execute. | Check Schwab Order Status first, so you don't repeat trades that are already placed. Then select **Optimize** on the account's **Optimization** tab, and review and approve the new proposal. See [Cancel a trade file](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-by-file-at-schwab.md#cancel-a-trade-file). |
| **Not submitted** | Your firm reported that none of the file's trades were submitted. Tilt goes by that report and can't confirm it. | To trade the account, select **Optimize** on its **Optimization** tab, then review and approve the new proposal. |
| A count that is **dropped** or **returned to review** | The custodian rejected those trades, and your firm decided each one. | For a returned trade, select **Optimize** on the account's **Optimization** tab, then review and approve the new proposal. |
| **In a trade file** | The account's trades went into more than one trade file. | Open each file from the **Sent** list to see how it ended. |

**To review** lists the accounts of the latest daily check. Tilt matches a file's trades when it imports the custodian's next daily files, and it runs that day's check straight after. A row that reads **Execution accounted for** is therefore soon replaced by the account's row from the new check. After that, open the file from the **Sent** list to see how it ended.

The list reads each note when it loads. If someone cancels the file or records a submission report while you have **Trading** open, select **Refresh status** to see the new note.

### Wait or follow

These rows need nothing from you on this list. Follow their sends on the **Sent** list.

| Status | What it means |
| - | - |
| **Optimizing** | Tilt is making a new proposal. The list updates when it is ready. |
| **Approved** | The approval is recorded. **Not sent yet** in **Notes** means its trades are waiting to go out. |
| **Sending**, **Sent**, **Partly filled**, **Filled** | The account's orders are on their way to the custodian or are there. **Notes** read **Waiting for Alpaca** or count the fills, for example **2 of 4 filled**. |
| **Canceled** | The account's orders ended before all of them filled. **Notes** count the ones that filled first. |

### Nothing to do

| Status | What it means |
| - | - |
| **Recorded as executed** | The proposal's trades are recorded as done. |
| **No trades needed** | The proposal is finished and has no trades. Choose **All** in the menu to find the row. |

## 3. Approve the accounts

1. Select the checkbox of each account you want to trade. Accounts that are optimized together share one decision: select their grouping row's checkbox to take them all.
2. Select the approve button below the list. It reads **Approve and send** when the accounts send orders to your custodian, and **Approve** when they go to a trade file or the approval places no trades.
3. Read the confirmation. It lists the accounts, the orders, and the buys and sells, and its note says whether Tilt places orders.
4. Confirm.

![Approve 3 accounts? dialog listing Accounts 3 accounts, Orders 12 day limit orders, Buys \$50,458, Sells \$47,618, Est. tax \$0, and Custodian Trade file for the custodian. It says: This records your approval and adds these accounts' trades to the trade file. You can approve more accounts before downloading. No trades are placed. Buttons: Cancel and Approve 3 accounts.](https://mintcdn.com/tilt/YZs0AAK5ogteslHt/images/advisor/trading-approve-dialog.jpg?fit=max\&auto=format\&n=YZs0AAK5ogteslHt\&q=85\&s=22032608fac55fdcb29244ac70ac6273)

The confirmation for three accounts whose trades go to a trade file.

| The confirmation says | What confirming does |
| - | - |
| **Orders can't be recalled once Alpaca accepts them.** | Sends the orders to the custodian. |
| **This records your approval and adds these accounts' trades to the trade file.** | Adds the trades to a [trade file](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-by-file-at-schwab.md). Tilt places no orders. |
| **This records the approval. No trades are placed.** | Records the approval only. You get this when the accounts have no linked custodian account, or when you can approve but not send. |

If Tilt refuses, the list says **Approval was not recorded.** with the reason, and reads the proposals again. These reasons need a step outside the dialog:

| Reason | What to do |
| - | - |
| A reason that begins **Inputs changed after optimization** | [Re-run the optimization](#re-run-the-optimization). |
| **A newer optimization exists for this account. Review that proposal.** | Open the account and review its newer proposal. |
| **Accounts optimized together are approved together.** | Select the grouping row's checkbox so the approval covers every account the reason names. |
| A reason that begins **This account is paused because trade file** | [Finish the trade file](https://docs.tilt.now/advisor/trade-by-file-at-schwab.md) that holds the account. |

## 4. Follow the send

When a send reaches the custodian, Tilt opens that send's page. In other cases you stay on the list, and a notice above it reports the result.

The **Sent** list shows each send and trade file with its **Progress** and **Status**. Its **Needs attention** tab holds the sends where a trade was blocked, rejected, canceled, or only partly filled, and the trade files reported as partly submitted or uncertain. Select a row to open the send or the file.

## Re-run the optimization

Select **Re-run optimization** at the top of the page to make new proposals from current holdings and settings. Tilt makes one for each listed account that is still undecided: rows that read **Needs review** or **No trades needed**, and **Needs attention** rows whose proposal failed, is missing, or is out of date, or whose send stopped before any order was placed. It leaves every other approved account alone, along with sent, paused, and skipped accounts. The re-run rows read **Optimizing** until the new proposals replace the old ones.

The button appears for owners and editors when the list has an account to re-run.


This documentation is built and hosted on [Mintlify](https://mintlify.com), a developer documentation platform.